GM microbes: European Commission steps back from enforcing EU rules

In its response to a par­lia­men­tary ques­tion, the Euro­pean Com­mis­sion has made clear that it no longer intends to take the lead in inves­ti­gat­ing whether unau­tho­rised genet­i­cal­ly mod­i­fied microor­gan­isms (GMMs) could enter the EU through imports. Mean­while, a Com­mis­sion pro­pos­al to weak­en exist­ing safe­guards for the envi­ron­men­tal release of GMMs is advanc­ing through the EU leg­isla­tive process, with the Euro­pean Par­lia­ment due to vote on it next week. Sci­en­tists and cit­i­zens have opposed the pro­posed changes.

Commission unconcerned about unauthorised GMO imports

The Commission’s new hands-off approach is appar­ent from its answer to a par­lia­men­tary ques­tion con­cern­ing Bio­mElix® One, a feed addi­tive based on genet­i­cal­ly mod­i­fied bac­te­ria. The prod­uct is designed to spread engi­neered CRISPR-car­ry­ing plas­mids – small, cir­cu­lar pieces of repli­cat­ing DNA – through the bac­te­r­i­al com­mu­ni­ties in chick­en guts. When these engi­neered plas­mids enter Sal­mo­nel­la bac­te­ria, they cut the bacteria’s chro­mo­so­mal DNA and kill them. In oth­er bac­te­ria, they do not cut the chro­mo­somes. How­ev­er, each suc­cess­ful trans­fer of an engi­neered plas­mid cre­ates a new, liv­ing genet­i­cal­ly mod­i­fied microor­gan­ism. Bio­mElix® One has been approved in Brazil since Decem­ber 2024.

An MEP asked whether the Com­mis­sion con­sid­ered that “any liv­ing mod­i­fied organ­ism car­ry­ing genet­i­cal­ly mod­i­fied plas­mids in Brazil­ian poul­try imports [into the EU] con­sti­tutes an unau­tho­rised release”. Rather than address­ing this ques­tion, the Com­mis­sion replied that the fact that “feed addi­tives con­tain a mod­i­fied plas­mid does not per se ren­der ani­mals fed with that feed addi­tive a GMO”.

The Com­mis­sion also said it had not dis­cussed “this spe­cif­ic feed addi­tive” with Mem­ber States or the Brazil­ian author­i­ties, and gave no indi­ca­tion that it intend­ed to do so. Instead, it empha­sised that “oper­a­tors with­in and out­side the EU bear pri­ma­ry respon­si­bil­i­ty” for com­pli­ance with the rules, while “Mem­ber States are respon­si­ble for import con­trols”.

This con­trasts sharply with past approach­es when the Com­mis­sion took up such con­cerns itself with export­ing coun­tries. In June 2014, after GeneWatch UK raised con­cerns about unau­tho­rised GM insects in fruit import­ed from Brazil, the Com­mis­sion request­ed infor­ma­tion from the Brazil­ian author­i­ties on how they would ensure the insects were not export­ed to the EU.

Existing EU protections for GM microbes under threat

In Decem­ber 2025, the Com­mis­sion pro­posed to dis­man­tle some of the exist­ing GMO rules specif­i­cal­ly for GMM prod­ucts released into the envi­ron­ment. Under the pro­pos­al, GMMs would be sub­ject to a lighter pre-mar­ket risk assess­ment, and require­ments for detec­tion meth­ods and post-mar­ket mon­i­tor­ing could be waived in some cas­es. EU GMM autho­ri­sa­tions would no longer be reviewed reg­u­lar­ly but would instead be valid for an unlim­it­ed dura­tion. The autho­ri­sa­tion of cer­tain GMMs would be fast-tracked based on the assump­tion that they pose “low risk”.

The Euro­pean Par­lia­ment, whilst agree­ing on the prin­ci­ple of weak­en­ing exist­ing safe­guards, is not pre­pared to go quite so far. In a com­mit­tee vote on 10 Novem­ber, MEPs vot­ed to main­tain detectabil­i­ty and post-mar­ket envi­ron­men­tal mon­i­tor­ing for all EU-autho­rised GMMs, and to review all EU GMM autho­ri­sa­tions after the first 10 years.  MEPs also vot­ed to reduce the scope of GMMs eli­gi­ble for a fast-track autho­ri­sa­tion pro­ce­dure.

The Parliament’s ple­nary will vote on the new rules on 25 Novem­ber. Save Our Seeds, along­side many oth­er organ­i­sa­tions, has called on MEPs to reject the pro­posed weak­en­ing of EU safe­guards. EU min­is­ters had already agreed on the Council’s posi­tion in June, mak­ing only lim­it­ed changes to the Com­mis­sion pro­pos­al.

German scientists warn against lowering safety standards

The Asso­ci­a­tion of Ger­man Sci­en­tists (VDW) has now issued a state­ment oppos­ing low­er safe­ty stan­dards for the envi­ron­men­tal release of GMMs. Accord­ing to the sci­en­tists, GMMs must not be released into the envi­ron­ment with­out an inde­pen­dent, case-by-case risk assess­ment, manda­to­ry long-term envi­ron­men­tal mon­i­tor­ing and time-lim­it­ed autho­ri­sa­tions. This is because GMMs can repro­duce, estab­lish them­selves in ecosys­tems and poten­tial­ly trans­fer genet­ic mate­r­i­al to oth­er organ­isms. Once released, their spread may be impos­si­ble to reverse.

The VDW’s con­cerns echo those of Euro­pean eco­log­i­cal sci­en­tists and a group of most­ly French sci­en­tists who have urged the EU, in an appeal pub­lished in the French news­pa­per Le Monde, to sus­pend the debate on the pro­posed law and broad­en the debate before con­sid­er­ing any weak­en­ing of exist­ing stan­dards (Eng­lish ver­sion here).

What happens next?

The Euro­pean Par­lia­ment is due to vote on its posi­tion on the pro­posed rules on 25 Novem­ber in Stras­bourg. Once Par­lia­ment has adopt­ed its posi­tion, nego­ti­a­tions between Par­lia­ment, the Coun­cil and the Com­mis­sion – known as tri­logue talks – will begin to agree on the final text.

Save Our Seeds, togeth­er with almost 20 part­ner organ­i­sa­tions from sev­er­al EU coun­tries, has launched a joint peti­tion call­ing for robust safe­guards against the release of GMMs into the envi­ron­ment. We will bring the peti­tion, along­side the con­cerns raised by sci­en­tists, to EU deci­sion-mak­ers. Our mes­sage is clear: when envi­ron­men­tal impacts could be irre­versible, pre­cau­tion must come first.

The image image shows Olivér Várhe­lyi, Euro­pean Com­mis­sion­er for Health and Ani­mal Wel­fare

Pho­to © Euro­pean Union, 2026, licensed under CC BY 4.0

to top